Finding the right letting or estate agent in Peterborough is not a decision to leave to chance. Whether you’re a landlord protecting an investment, a tenant searching for a home, or an investor growing a portfolio, the agent you appoint will directly shape your outcome.
With so many agencies competing for your business in 2026, this guide cuts through the noise, covering 9 highly rated letting and estate agents in Peterborough and making a clear case for which one leads the pack.
Why it matters in 2026
Peterborough remains one of the East of England’s most accessible property markets, with average sold prices around £232,000 according to recent ONS data (December 2025) and Rightmove trends near £253,000 over the past year [1].
Rental demand continues to outpace supply, and the legislative environment, such as the EPC requirements, the Renters Reform Bill and the removal of Section 21, means choosing the right agent is more consequential than ever. Your agent isn’t just an administrative convenience; they are a compliance partner and a buffer against costly risk.
How we evaluated each agent
Agents were assessed on Google and Trustpilot review scores, breadth of services, ARLA Propertymark accreditation, fee transparency, responsiveness and genuine local market knowledge.
No sponsored placements influenced this list.
The 9 best letting and estate agents in Peterborough
| Agent | Speciality | Rating | Best for | ARLA/PropertyMark |
| Progressive Lets | Lettings & Management | 4.9/5 | Landlords & Tenants | Yes |
| William H Brown | Sales & Lettings | 4.4/5 | Buyers & Sellers | Yes |
| Mandairs Estate Agents | Sales & Lettings | 4.6/5 | Landlords & Investors | Yes |
| Firmin & Co | Residential Sales | 4.5/5 | First-Time Buyers | Yes |
| Sharman Quinney | Sales & Lettings | 4.3/5 | All Users | Yes |
| PropertyLine | Lettings & Sales | 4.2/5 | Budget-Conscious Landlords | Partial |
| Purplebricks | Online Sales | 3.8/5 | DIY Sellers | No |
| Cookes Property | Lettings Management | 4.4/5 | Local Landlords | Yes |
| Blenheim Sales & Lettings | Sales & Lettings | 4.5/5 | Landlords & Sellers | Yes |
1. Progressive Lets
Company Name: Progressive Lets Ltd.
Address: 10 Office Village, Forder Way, Cygnet Park, Hampton, Peterborough, PE7 8GX
Phone: 01733 293900
Email: info@progressivelets.co.uk
Website: https://progressivelets.co.uk/
This company is the go-to choice for private landlords and portfolio investors who want dependable management without surprises.
Pros:
- Specialist lettings focus with sharp compliance knowledge
- Transparent fees with no hidden charges
- Consistently high ratings from both landlords and tenants
Cons:
- No residential sales service
- Peterborough-focused; limited national reach
2. William H Brown
Company Name: William H Brown
Address: 6-9 Fortune Buildings Cowgate, Peterborough, Cambridgeshire, PE1 1LR
Phone: 01733 311022 (Sales); 01733 553545 (Lettings)
Email: Via website contact form
Website: https://www.williamhbrown.co.uk/
William H Brown is part of the Sequence Group, the agency that brings national infrastructure to the Peterborough market, covering both sales and lettings. Reliable for valuations and brand-backed processes, though the experience can feel less personal than an independent.
Pros:
- Established national brand with local presence
- Covers sales and lettings under one roof
Cons:
- Some reviews flag slower response times
- Less personalised service than independents
3. Mandairs Estate Agency
Company Name: Mandairs Estate Agents
Address: Unit 1, 134 High Street, Old Fletton, Peterborough, PE2 8DP
Phone: 01733 794200
Email: info@mandairs.co.uk
Website: www.mandairs.co.uk
Mandairs Estate Agency is a respected Peterborough-rooted independent known for plain-speaking advice and honest market assessments. Particularly well-regarded by landlords and investors who value candid portfolio guidance over corporate polish.
Pros:
- Genuinely local with honest, jargon-free advice
- Strong fit for landlords and property investors
Cons:
- Smaller team may limit capacity at busy times
- Lower brand visibility than national chains
4. Firmin & Co
Company Name: Firmin & Co
Address: 381 Eastfield Road, Peterborough, PE1 4RA
Phone: 01733 834727
Email: Peterborough@firminandco.co.uk
Website: https://www.firminandco.co.uk/
Firmin & Co is a long-standing Peterborough agency with over a decade of neighbourhood knowledge, focused primarily on residential sales. Their patient, clear guidance makes them a popular choice for first-time buyers navigating the process.
Pros:
- Deep local knowledge built over many decades
- Strong reputation with first-time buyers
Cons:
- Limited lettings offering
- Less suited to investors or portfolio landlords
5. Sharman Quinney
Company Name: Sharman Quinney
Address: 70 Albert Place, Peterborough, Cambridgeshire PE1 1DD
Phone: 01733 897896
Email: Via website contact form
Website: https://www.sharmanquinney.co.uk/
Sharman Quinney has multiple Peterborough branches covering areas from Orton to Werrington. The company offers a wide local reach for both sales and lettings clients. A solid middle-ground option for those who value coverage and convenience.
Pros:
- Multi-branch network across Peterborough
- Handles both sales and lettings
Cons:
- Service quality can vary between branches
- Less personal than single-office independents
6. PropertyLine
Company Name: Property Line
Address: 75 Broadway, Peterborough, PE1 1SY
Phone: 01733 777788
Email: info@epropertyline.com
Website: https://epropertyline.com/
PropertyLine is an established Peterborough independent with 20+ years of experience, offering full sales/lettings at competitive rates, with digital tools such as virtual tours.
Pros:
- Competitive pricing for let-only and rent collection
- Straightforward, no-frills processes
Cons:
- Limited support for complex management needs
- Not fully Propertymark accredited
7. Purplebricks
Company Name: Purplebricks Property Limited
Phone: 0800 810 8008 (Sales); 0800 810 8419 (Lettings)
Email: Via website contact form
Website: https://www.purplebricks.co.uk/
Purplebricks offers a fixed-fee, online-first approach that can reduce costs for confident, self-directed sellers. However, upfront fees apply regardless of outcome and local support quality varies depending on the assigned agent.
Pros:
- Fixed fee can save money versus commission-based models
- National portal exposure for listings
Cons:
- Fees charged even if the property does not sell
- Inconsistent local support and mixed reviews
8. Cookes Property
Company Name: Cookes Property
Address: Unit 9, Wharf Road Industrial Estate, Wharf Road, Woodston, Peterborough, PE2 9PS
Phone: 01733 312338
Email: info@cookesproperty.co.uk
Website: https://www.cookesproperty.co.uk/
Cookes Property is a quality-focused independent agency (est. 1999) with a strong reputation for property presentation, attentive landlord/tenant communication and efficient lettings management. Sales are supported as a secondary service.
Pros:
- High-quality photography and property marketing
- Well-reviewed for communication and seller care
Cons:
- Lettings is not the primary focus
- Limited capacity during peak periods
9. Blenheim Sales & Lettings
Company Name: Blenheim Sales & Lettings
Address: 5, Blenheim Court, Peppercorn Cl, Peterborough PE1 2DU
Phone: 01733 639055
Email: info@blenheimlettings.co.uk
Website: https://www.blenheimlettings.co.uk/
Blenheim Sales & Lettings is a locally trusted agency covering both sales and lettings, including some commercial property. Known for professional consistency, honest valuations and strong aftercare, without the bureaucracy of a national chain.
Pros:
- Covers sales, lettings and some commercial property
- Strong aftercare and client communication
Cons:
- Smaller team can slow response during busy periods
- Technology offering lags behind some competitors
Why Progressive Lets is the clear winner for 2026
Progressive Lets specialises exclusively in lettings and property management in Peterborough. This focus aligns with 2026 landlord needs amid stricter regulations, such as EPC requirements and the Renters Reform Act.
Key differentiators
Their lettings-only model emphasises compliance support, tenant vetting and maintenance coordination, as noted in landlord testimonials. Reviews highlight proactive communication that helps minimise voids and handle deposit issues.
Comparative fit
Compared to full-service agencies, Progressive Lets offers transparent fees and local expertise without sales distractions. Recent feedback confirms consistent service for both landlords and tenants.
What to look for when choosing a letting agent
Before committing to any agent, use this expanded checklist to evaluate suitability.
- Verify accreditations: Confirm ARLA Propertymark membership (ensures client money protection and professional standards) and request a detailed written fee breakdown covering setup, renewals, maintenance and any extras.
- Test responsiveness: Contact via phone/email during business hours to gauge response times; aim for under 24 hours for initial replies.
- Review service scope: Ask about inventory checks, rent guarantee options, maintenance processes and deposit protection schemes and match to your self-management capacity.
- Check ratings and feedback: Use letting agent directories for verified scores, plus reviews and Reddit threads for unfiltered landlord/tenant experiences.
- Assess local market knowledge: Request recent comparable rental data for your property type/area to confirm pricing accuracy and void minimisation strategies.
- Confirm legal compliance: Ensure they handle EPC requirements, Renters Reform Act updates and Right to Rent checks proactively.
This systematic approach helps identify agents balancing cost, reliability and regulatory expertise.
The bottom line
Each of the nine agencies listed here has genuine strengths. But for landlords and tenants who want specialist expertise, proactive compliance support and transparent pricing in 2026, one name rises above the rest.
Visit the Progressive Lets website https://progressivelets.co.uk/ to discuss your property needs and find out what truly professional lettings management looks like.
FAQs
What do letting agents in Peterborough typically charge?
Let-only services usually cost 8–12% of annual rent as a one-off fee. Full management runs 10–15% of monthly rent on an ongoing basis. Always request a full written schedule before signing.
Is professional management worth it?
For landlords with multiple properties, limited time, or properties far from home, yes. Better tenant retention, faster void filling and compliance protection typically outweigh the management fee.
How do I know if an agent is regulated?
Check for membership of The Property Ombudsman or the Property Redress Scheme. Agents handling client money must hold Client Money Protection insurance. ARLA Propertymark membership adds further professional standards.
References:
- Office for National Statistics. (2026). Housing prices in Peterborough.
https://www.ons.gov.uk/visualisations/housingpriceslocal/E06000031/